No One Gets an A: Distributional Bias in LLM Text Scoring
Research study · First author · 2026
Designed a study of 11 LLMs and ~99,000 text assessments to test whether 0-10 writing scores reflected deliberate reductions in text quality.
Compared five scoring corrections. Probability-weighted scoring increased correct rankings of better versus degraded text from 51.8% to 64.9% across nine models.